Foreign Bidders on Highway 121 Project Would "Buy American"
Texans should welcome new jobs and other benefits of "reverse outsourcing"
By Leonard C. Gilroy, AICP

Collin County commissioner Phyllis Cole's recent opinion piece ("NTTA is the best choice for 121 construction," June 23) suggests that granting the Highway 121 toll road contract to the NTTA equates to "buying American." The irony is that is exactly what Cintra, the Spanish firm that originally won the competitively bid 121 contract, would be doing if it wins the contract.

Shouldn't we welcome the investment of billions of dollars in global capital in the state and region rather than shun it? Under Cintra's proposal, the bulk of the jobs and services needed for the 121 project would come from within the state and region, not from overseas. This is exactly the kind of "reverse outsourcing" that Texans should welcome.

Cole also completely ignores the findings of the RTC's financial experts who concluded that the NTTA proposal is far riskier to the region than Cintra's and is hardly the "best financial deal" for the Metroplex, as she claims. Stretching its bond capacity now increases the risk that NTTA won't be able to generate the financing needed in the future to get its already-planned projects built.

Lastly, to make the financing work, NTTA would have to commit to regular toll increases upfront to keep pace with inflation, just as Cintra would. If revenues don't live up to expectations, Cintra would absorb any financial losses and would be locked in to legally-enforceable contractual caps on toll rate increases. However, if NTTA faced the same situation, there are no guarantees. Its bond covenants could require it to raise tolls on all of its roads as much as necessary to cover its debt obligations.

When you add it all up, it's clear that NTTA's proposal entails far more risk to Metroplex commuters and businesses than Cintra's, and it's not the best solution for meeting the region's mobility needs.

Leonard Gilroy is a Houston-based certified planner and senior policy analyst with the Reason Foundation. An archive of his work is here, and Reason's transportation research and commentary is here.

Related Studies

Pennsylvania Turnpike Alternatives: A Review and Critique of the Democratic Caucus Study
 » News Release
 » Full Policy Brief (.pdf)

Missouri's Changing Transportation Paradigm
 » Full Report (.pdf)
 » Policy Summary (.pdf)

Miami Toll Truckway: Preliminary Feasibility Study
 » Full Text (.pdf)

Raising Gas Taxes Won't Fix Our Bridges
 » Full Text (.pdf)

Why Mobility Matters to Personal Life
 » Full Brief (.pdf)

16th Annual Report on the Performance of State Highway Systems (1984–2005)
 » Press Release
 » Full Study (.pdf)
 » Map, Tables, and More Materials from this Study

Leasing the Pennsylvania Turnpike: A Response to Critics of Gov. Rendell's Plan
 » Full Study (.pdf)

Tolling and Public-Private Partnerships in Texas: Separating Myth from Fact
 » Full Study (.pdf)
 » Press Release

The Role of Tolls in Financing 21st Century Highways
 » Full Study (.pdf)
 » Policy Summary (.pdf)
 » Press Release

Building New Roads Through Public-Private Partnerships: Frequently Asked Questions
 » Full Brief (.pdf)

More Transportation Studies

Related Commentary

Virginia Saving Money With Fixed-Price Interstate Maintenance Deal
 » Full Text

Stretching the Highway Dollar
 » Full Text

Infrastructure Investment, Congestion and Rail
 » Full Text

Feds Don't Need Bigger Role in Public-Private Partnerships
 » Full Text

Private Sector Has the Key to Traffic Woes in Arizona
 » Full Text

Greenway Toll Bill Could Make it Harder to Fund, Build Roads
 » Full Text

Battle Continues Over Highway Paradigm Shift
 » Full Text

More Transportation Commentaries